HIS- 5-3-1 Activity: Historical Context Chart 4/7/19
Table of Contents
Historical Context Chart
- Identify three secondary sources from your selected topic. The secondary resources will review three historical events that impacted your research topic. Complete the Historical Context Chart to explore the how these events inform the historical context of your topic and support your thesis statement.
- Download and complete the Historical Context Chart. Save this chart as a file on your computer. Submit this saved file for instructor grading and feedback.
Prompt: Historiography is the practice of analyzing how the historical context of a time influences how historians write about and interpret historical events. First, choose three secondary sources that discuss three historical events that influence your research topic
Next, explain in the chart how the event impacted the historical context of your research topic. Then describe whether the historical context of the event supports your thesis statement for your research topic.
|Article Citation and Name of Event||Historical Context of Event||Impact of Historical Context on Thesis Statement|
Short Response: Research Plan Preparation
4-2-1 Short Response: Research Plan Preparation
Top of Form
Bottom of Form
HIS-100-X4685 Perspectives in History 19EW4
My first question was: “How was the drafting of the United States constitution significant towards protecting the American people”
This should be revised to: “Did the drafting of the United States constitution assist in ensuring checks and balances among the powers of governance”
I decided to revise my topic because I wanted to be more specific on the exact choice of topic for discussion. (White, 2017) The drafting of the constitution plays an important role in protecting American citizens, however there are various ways it depicts its uniqueness: however, to be more specific the revised topic puts emphasis on the United States constitution and checks and balances.
I would discuss further on the importance of the United States constitution and how it ensured checks and balances are part of the government’s instruments for controlling powers of governance. My research aims at explaining specifically on how the founding fathers who drafted the constitution included checks and balances in order to override control of power which has to be monitored. (Urban, 2018)
Beeman, R. R. (2010). Plain, honest men: The making of the American Constitution. New York: Random House Trade Paperbacks. Primary source as part of the research would contribute significantly in bringing out my specific idea of the message I want to pass across.
The selected primary source for instance “Plain honest men” expounds further on the expertise involved during the drafting of the US constitution: furthermore it also gives information related to checks and balances during its drafting. Primary source would also create a firm foundation for the secondary source when it comes to supporting the research topic.
My second question was: “How did the founding fathers set up the US constitution guidelines?”
This should be revised to: “Did the framers of the U.S constitution include guidelines for dealing with future situations?”
The intention of revising my research question was to ensure the discussion topic was narrower in regards to getting results which are accurate in accordance to my choice of topic question. In trying to understand the process involved during the drafting of the constitution and their intention to offer guidelines; it is necessary to specify on how long it is supposed to protect the people.
The research topic I chose first was too general hence it could not bring out my intended purpose of selecting a research topic. In conducting my research I will try to understand better if the framers of the constitution created guidelines which were supposed to last for future generations. A good research topic is supposed to bring out the main purpose of the study, this is such as for instance in my study it is guidelines of the constitution and how it as meant for the future. (Browne, 2011)
United States & Important Books (Firm). (2014).The Constitution of the United States of America. Primary sources in this research question would enable me to have a deeper understanding in regards to the history of writing of the constitution by the founding fathers. Furthermore with the information received from the primary source I would try to understand in a critically how it contributes to my research topic. Moreover I would also integrate the secondary source with the primary source discussed hence compare and contrast the information explained.
Urban, J. B., & Van, E.-M. B. (2018). Designing and proposing your research project.
Browne, M. N., & Keeley, S. M. (2011). Asking the right questions: A guide to critical thinking. Boston: Pearson.
White, P. (2017). Developing research questions.
TOPIC EXPLORATION WORKSHEET
HIS 100 THEME 1
Select a research topic area for Project 1 based on which of the following areas interests you the most. You will explore the selected topic a little later in this theme. Mark your selection in the right-hand column.
|Drafting of the U.S. Constitution|
|Mao Zedong’s Rule Over China|
|South African Apartheid||·|
|Choose Your Own Topic|
|In the space below, write a short paragraph about what you already knew about the topic you selected prior to this course, based on your personal history or experiences. This may include assumptions, beliefs, or values related to the topic. Be as detailed as possible.|
|I recall when I was still in school the first time through the South African Apartheid was continually on the news. I recall the arrival of Nelson Mandela following 27 years of detainment in my sophomore year of secondary school. It’s my understanding that Apartheid was much similar to the racial isolation Martin Luther King battled against in the United States. I’m uncertain yet anticipate examining the effect that had on South Africa’s relations with other increasingly ground breaking nations.|
Now that you have identified your topic and described what you already know about the topic, what questions do you still have about the topic that you would like to know? Place your answers in the right-hand column.
|Identify one question about the topic that you are curious about.||How did other nations respond toward the South African Apartheid?|
|Describe why this question matters to you personally.||I experienced my childhood in a community where prejudice didn’t exist superficially (or maybe I was blind to it, yet black colleagues have affirmed it wasn’t there when we were growing up). I trust the more I think about it the more I can battle it.|
|Describe why this question matters to society.||Discussion of the “racial division” is more common now than I can ever recall it being. I believe it’s vital for individuals of all races to think about and get bigotry and how it’s not to anybody’s advantage.|
|Identify a second question about the topic you are curious about.||When was politically-sanctioned racial segregation established? To what extent did it last?|
|Describe why this question matters to you personally.||It doesn’t|
|Describe why this question matters to society.||Understanding the timespan may help decide the mood of the members. It appears that racial discrimination was endured all the more amid certain timespans.|
You are now ready to complete the final part of your Topic Exploration Worksheet. You have chosen a topic, posed some research questions, and are ready to start thinking about what kind of sources you will need to investigate your research questions further. Using the library guide in the Shapiro Library provided for your chosen topic, skim through the suggested resources (or find your own) and complete the following information for your research questions.
|List which secondary sources would be helpful for investigating your first research question.||Baines, G. (July 01, 2010). South Africa: Remembering Sharpeville. History Today, 60, 7.)|
|List which primary sourceswould be helpful for investigating your first research question.||Remembering Sharpeville – Gary Baines explores the impact of the massacre of black South Africans that took place 50 years ago. (January 01, 2010). History Today, 60, 3, 34.|
|List which secondary sources would be helpful for investigating your second research question.||Lodge, T. (2011). Sharpeville: an apartheid massacre and its consequences. OUP Oxford.|
|List which primary sources would be helpful for investigating your second research question.||Dlamini, P. (2018, March 21). Sharpeville massacre: Survivors say their dreams of better days are fading. Retrieved from Times Live: https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2018-03-21-sharpeville-massacre-survivors-say-their-dreams-of-better-days-are-fading/|
(Continued on next page)